Ever felt a sharp pinch at the front of your shoulder halfway through an upright row and kept going anyway?
If so, you’re not alone. The upright row is a favorite for building the traps and side delts, but it’s also one of the exercises lifters most often blame for shoulder pain. The good news is you don’t need it to build strong, good-looking shoulders. Plenty of upright row alternatives train the same muscles with far less stress on your joints.
As a certified personal trainer, I’ve swapped this exercise out for many clients over the years. Here’s what to do instead, and why it works.
Why the Upright Row Bothers So Many Shoulders
The upright row pulls the bar up the front of your body while your arms rotate inward and lift above shoulder height. That position can squeeze the small space under the top of your shoulder blade, called the subacromial space. The tendons of your rotator cuff pass through this space, and when it gets crowded, they can get irritated.
This is often called shoulder impingement, and it’s commonly cited as one of the leading causes of shoulder pain. Studies estimate that roughly one in five adults deals with shoulder pain at some point, and lifters are no exception.
Not everyone gets hurt by upright rows. Some people do them for years with no trouble. But if you have a history of shoulder pain, sit at a desk all day, or feel a pinch when you lift, a smarter swap is worth it.
What Makes a Good Substitute?
A good replacement should do four things:
- Keep working your upper traps and side delts
- Let your shoulders stay in a more comfortable, natural position
- Allow you to add weight or reps over time
- Fit the equipment you actually have
Every exercise below meets those standards.
The Best Upright Row Alternatives

1. Lateral Raises
This is the go-to move for wider-looking shoulders. It targets the medial deltoid, the muscle that gives your shoulders their width.
How to do it:
- Stand tall with a light dumbbell in each hand.
- Keep a soft bend in your elbows.
- Raise your arms out to the sides until your hands reach about shoulder height.
- Lower slowly over two to three seconds.
Sets and reps: 3 sets of 12 to 15.
Common mistake: Using too much weight and swinging your body. Go lighter than you think. Cables are a great option because they keep tension on the muscle the whole time.
2. Face Pulls
If I could make every client do one shoulder exercise, it would be this one. Face pulls work your rear delts, upper back, and the small rotator cuff muscles that keep your shoulder healthy.
How to do it:
- Set a cable at about upper chest or face height with a rope attachment.
- Pull the rope toward your face, spreading your hands apart.
- Squeeze your shoulder blades together at the end.
- Return slowly.
Sets and reps: 3 sets of 12 to 20.
Why it helps: The outward rotation is the opposite of the upright row position, which makes it a great balance for your joints.
3. Dumbbell or Barbell Shrugs
Want bigger traps? Shrugs are the most direct answer. They load the upper trapezius without forcing your arms into that inward-rotated position.
How to do it:
- Hold weights at your sides with arms straight.
- Lift your shoulders straight up toward your ears.
- Pause for a second at the top.
- Lower slowly.
Sets and reps: 3 to 4 sets of 8 to 12.
Common mistake: Rolling your shoulders in circles. It adds nothing and can irritate the joint. Go straight up and straight down.
4. Dumbbell Overhead Press
Pressing builds overall shoulder size and strength better than almost anything else. Dumbbells let your arms move naturally, which is easier on the joint than a fixed barbell path.
How to do it:
- Sit or stand with dumbbells at shoulder height, palms facing forward or slightly inward.
- Press overhead without arching your lower back.
- Lower under control.
Sets and reps: 3 sets of 6 to 10.
A neutral grip, with palms facing each other, is often more comfortable if your shoulders feel cranky.
5. Landmine Press
This one is a hidden gem. The bar travels at an angle, so your shoulder blade can move freely. Many people with pinchy shoulders find this press feels smooth and pain-free.
How to do it:
- Wedge one end of a barbell into a corner or landmine attachment.
- Hold the other end at your shoulder.
- Press up and forward until your arm is straight.
- Lower slowly.
Sets and reps: 3 sets of 8 to 10 per arm.
6. Rear Delt Fly
Strong rear delts help your posture and balance out all the pressing you do. They also make your shoulders look rounder from every angle.
How to do it:
- Hinge forward at the hips with a flat back, or sit on a reverse pec deck.
- Raise your arms out to the sides, leading with your elbows.
- Squeeze at the top, then lower.
Sets and reps: 3 sets of 12 to 15.
7. Y-Raises
Y-raises train the lower traps, which are often weak in people who sit a lot. Strong lower traps help your shoulder blade move properly.
How to do it:
- Lie face down on an incline bench or stand bent over.
- With thumbs pointing up, raise your arms in a Y shape.
- Hold briefly, then lower.
Sets and reps: 2 to 3 sets of 10 to 12 with very light weight.
8. Scaption
Scaption is a raise in the scapular plane, about 30 degrees in front of your sides. This angle matches how your shoulder blade naturally moves, so it usually feels smoother than a straight lateral raise.
Sets and reps: 3 sets of 10 to 12 with light dumbbells.
9. Farmer’s Carries
Sometimes the simplest option works best. Walking while holding heavy weights loads your traps, grip, and core all at once.
How to do it: Hold heavy dumbbells at your sides, stand tall, and walk 30 to 40 seconds.
Sets: 3 rounds.
10. Modified Cable Upright Row
If you love the movement and want something close, make it safer. Use a cable, take a wider grip, and stop when your hands reach lower chest height instead of pulling up to your chin. Keep your wrists neutral. This keeps most of the benefit with less joint stress.
Choosing the Right Exercise for Your Goal
- Bigger upper traps: Shrugs and farmer’s carries
- Wider shoulders: Lateral raises and scaption
- Better posture: Face pulls, rear delt flys, and Y-raises
- Overall shoulder size: Dumbbell press and landmine press
- Beginners: Lateral raises, shrugs, and face pulls with light weight
- Sensitive shoulders: Landmine press, scaption, and face pulls
No Gym? No Problem
You can still train well at home. Resistance bands work for face pulls, lateral raises, and band pull-aparts. Bodyweight options include pike push-ups and prone Y-T-W raises on the floor. Even a backpack filled with books can stand in for a dumbbell on shrugs.
A Simple Sample Workout
Here’s an easy routine to replace upright rows, done once or twice a week:
- Dumbbell overhead press: 3 sets of 8
- Lateral raises: 3 sets of 12
- Face pulls: 3 sets of 15
- Shrugs: 3 sets of 10
Rest 60 to 90 seconds between sets. When you can complete all reps with good form, increase the weight slightly or add a rep or two. This is called progressive overload, and it’s what drives muscle growth.
Tips to Protect Your Shoulders in Any Exercise
- Warm up with band pull-aparts and arm circles before lifting.
- Keep your shoulder blades steady and avoid shrugging unless the exercise calls for it.
- Balance your pressing with just as much pulling.
- Stretch your chest and work on upper back mobility, especially if you sit a lot.
- Stop if you feel sharp or pinching pain. Muscle burn is fine, joint pain is not.
A Quick Word From My Training Experience
In my own coaching, the most common change I see is simple. Clients who switch from upright rows to face pulls and lateral raises often tell me their shoulders feel better within a few weeks, while their results keep improving. Strength research backs this up: the side delts respond very well to lateral raises, and EMG studies show shrugs and presses strongly activate the traps and shoulders.
Final Thoughts
You don’t need the upright row to build strong, capable shoulders. Between lateral raises, face pulls, shrugs, and pressing variations, you have everything you need to grow your traps and delts while keeping your joints happy. Start with two or three of these moves, focus on clean form, and give your body a few weeks to adapt.